View photos

Menu Snapshot

  • Top categories (Snacks / Chips / Drinks / Specialties / Salads/Sides)
  • Most orders: $10–20
View Complete Menu

Overview & Highlights

If you find yourself in Cookstown, NJ, a visit to The Sandwich Shop LLC is an absolute must. This charming local eatery specializes in delectable sandwiches and comforting fried foods, making it a go-to spot for anyone seeking a satisfying meal in a laid-back environment.

The atmosphere of The Sandwich Shop LLC is friendly and casual, perfect for either a quick grab-and-go meal or a relaxed bite with some friends. Despite its modest seating, the bustling vibe only adds to the allure, promising a lively experience paired with the warm smiles of the staff who are always ready to assist you with your cravings.

On the menu, you're greeted with a captivating selection of fried foods that will tantalize your taste buds. Indulge in their Chicken Tenders—crispy on the outside and juicy within—perfectly complemented by a side of fresh French fries or tantalizing Chili Cheese Fries. If you're after something a bit more indulgent, make sure to try their Loaded Tater Tots topped with cheese and bacon; a dish that guarantees to satisfy any appetite.

When it comes to sandwiches, The Sandwich Shop prides itself on using fresh ingredients. Their Cold Subs like the Super Italian boast mountains of just-sliced, high-quality meats and cheese, made to order, ensuring each sub is bursting with flavor. Customers rave about the immense portion sizes and the freshness of the ingredients. As one happy patron notes, the sandwiches are "full of meat," making them not only delicious but also an incredible value.

If you’re in for breakfast, don’t miss out on their Hot Off The Griddle selection, particularly the Short Stack Pancakes or the French Toast. Imagine sinking your teeth into fluffy pancakes, perfectly golden-brown and served with a drizzle of syrup, making every bite a delight. And with every dish expertly prepared fresh to order, you’ll be treated to an unforgettable start to your day.

Customer reviews speak volumes about the charm of this establishment; they commend the consistently friendly service and the deliciousness of the food. "Very hard working people here!" states one satisfied customer, emphasizing the dedication to quality and care that the staff provides. Another patron appreciates the ability to order online, making it even easier for busy folks to enjoy their mouthwatering subs and wraps.

In a nutshell, The Sandwich Shop LLC isn’t just a place to grab a quick meal—it’s a beloved community fixture that prides itself on quality, flavor, and genuine hospitality. Whether you swing by for a leisurely lunch or a hearty breakfast, you can count on leaving fully satisfied, with a promise to return soon!

Visit The Sandwich Shop LLC at 26 Wrightstown Cookstown Rd, Cookstown, NJ 08511 or give them a call at +1 609-286-2170 to place your order today!

Comforts & Conveniences

Service options
  • Takeaway
  • Dine-in
Popular for
  • Breakfast
  • Lunch
  • Solo dining
Accessibility
  • Wheelchair-accessible car park
Payments
  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments
  • Credit cards

Where to Visit

Visitor Testimonials (295)

Nice sandwich shop. Super friendly service! Great selection was sandwiches, soups, hot sandwiches, cold sandwiches, potato chips, sodas, salads! Small inside with a few seats. Nice big sandwiches full of meat.

The best place around to get delicious Italian subs. I can vouch for their subs, sandwiches, mozzarella sticks, and cheese fries because they're my usual order. But, if the rest of their menu is as good what I usually order you can't go wrong. I absolutely love this place and you won't be disappointed !

The breakfast burritos are out of this world!! Everyone here is super nice & friendly, and love the fact that I can order online through Clover. Will definitely keep coming here

Pleasant wait staff, great sandwiches and sides. Fresh tasty sandwiches with very ample filling. Meat and cheese are sliced for your sandwich when you order, not pre-sliced ahead of time.

Very hard working people here! They are always busy, but that’s because the food is great. Employees are kind, prices are fair, and they have a nice selection of options to choose from. Not a sit down kind of place, but they do have a few barstools if you choose to.

I just tried this place today for a take-out lunch, and it was excellent. They freshly sliced the meat and cheese to order, which I can really appreciate! I ordered the Super Italian, and they didn't skimp on meat, plus the price was a good value. The bread was fresh and soft, too. I will definitely be back!

Very busy sandwich shop in a small town. Haven’t been to this particular place in many years. I think it has changed ownership since. Stopped in ordered two subs to go (an Italian and a roast beef and cheese.). $30 for two subs. I guess it’s about average these days. The subs are heavy, so I assumed they were going to be worth it based on weight alone. The meat was fresh and plentiful good quality lunchmeat All of the toppings were fresh. Order was done exactly as we asked. The bread is the part that makes the sub and they were on point. Overall, a very good sub. The staff is very good at what they do. They are quick and efficient and very nice to deal with. Definitely a go to if you are in the area just check the hours as they are not open late.

Tell Us About Your Visit

Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *

Service & Hospitality
Value for Money
Food & Drink Quality
Ambience & Comfort

Explore Similar Places Nearby

THE PLATING

562 Grand Ave, Englewood, NJ 07631, United States

  • 4.4 311 Ratings

Moxie Modern

202 Broadway, Long Branch, NJ 07740, United States

  • 4.4 260 Ratings

El Paraíso Hondureño

39 N Main St, Pleasantville, NJ 08232, United States

  • 3.6 285 Ratings

The Stirling Fountain

225 Main Ave, Stirling, NJ 07980, United States

  • 4.7 278 Ratings

Gallagher's Taproom

437 Pine St, Mt Holly, NJ 08060, United States

  • 4.3 286 Ratings

Primo Pizza

2230 Hamburg Tpke #2, Wayne, NJ 07470, United States

  • 4.6 413 Ratings

Rommadill Pickling Co

3109 Pacific Ave, Wildwood, NJ 08260, United States

  • 4.7 240 Ratings

Sparrowlight Kitchen African Restaurant, Deli, & Grocery

4500 Bordentown Ave #7, Sayreville, NJ 08872, United States

  • 3.1 237 Ratings

Latteria

95 Woodstown Rd I, Swedesboro, NJ 08085, United States

  • 4.8 858 Ratings

Zest Of Home Cuisine

1550 Summit Ave, Hillside, NJ 07205, United States

  • 4.8 223 Ratings

Discover More Places

Kilimanjar Coffee & Brunch

Calle Prof D. José Moya, 7, 30400 Caravaca de la Cruz, Murcia, Spain

  • 4.6 292 Ratings

Sushi Ghetto

Av. Acueducto 1625-loc E, Girasoles Elite, Girasoles Acueducto, 45138 Zapopan, Jal., Mexico

  • 4.5 1806 Ratings

Restaurante El Carmen. Bodas y Eventos

C. la Caleta, 18195 Belicena, Granada, Spain

  • 4.2 891 Ratings

Family's Burger

795 Avenue du 19 Mars 1962, 01100 Arbent, France

  • 3.7 757 Ratings

Little Yellow House CB

988 S Hemlock St, Cannon Beach, OR 97110, United States

  • 4.4 247 Ratings